PGA Tour duffs ethical excessive floor with LIV Golf merger
The BDN Editorial Board operates independently from the newsroom, and doesn’t set insurance policies or contribute to reporting or enhancing articles elsewhere within the newspaper or on bangordailynews.com.
Going low is often a superb factor in golf. However this week, the PGA Tour has gone low in a disappointing and deeply hypocritical approach.
After greater than a 12 months of buying and selling photographs with the upstart LIV Golf, which is backed by the sovereign wealth fund of Saudi Arabia led by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, PGA leaders have shortly gone from criticizing LIV (and gamers who be part of it) to doing enterprise with it. A merger of the 2 excursions was introduced this week. This was information even to PGA tour gamers, who had an understandably contentious assembly with tour commissioner Jay Monahan Tuesday night.
“It was contentious,” participant Johnson Wagner informed the Golf Channel, as reported by ESPN. “There have been many moments the place sure gamers had been calling for brand new management of the PGA Tour and even obtained a pair standing ovations.”
Monahan and PGA leaders are rightly being criticized as hypocrites, having beforehand been vital of the gamers who joined LIV whereas evoking the reminiscence of 9/11 victims. The Saudi authorities has been accused of being linked to these assaults (which it has repeatedly denied), and in addition confronted deserved criticism for its human rights document.
“I feel you’d need to be dwelling beneath a rock to not know that there are important implications,” Monahan said last June when requested about 9/11 victims’ households being vital of gamers becoming a member of LIV. “Because it pertains to the households of 9/11, I’ve two households which might be near me that misplaced family members. So my coronary heart goes out to them. And I might ask any participant that has left or any participant that may ever contemplate leaving, ‘Have you ever ever needed to apologize for being a member of the PGA Tour?’”
Final 12 months, Monahan was implying that being part of LIV was one thing to apologize for. Now his group is merging with LIV. So who must apologize now?
Mainly, it appears the PGA was prepared to make an ethical stand till it was financially useful to do in any other case. Maybe we shouldn’t be stunned. Cash talks. That’s sadly par for the course, in golf and in life. There was an identical disconnect between President Joe Biden’s marketing campaign rhetoric about treating Saudi Arabia as a “pariah” and his later journey to Saudi Arabia amid document gasoline costs. Clearly hypocrisy in authorities and enterprise is nothing new in the case of Saudi Arabia, its affect and its human rights document.
This doesn’t make the PGA’s abrupt change in fact any much less cynical. Nevertheless it does make it much less stunning.
One element that did shock us, and which may shock others to listen to, is that the PGA Tour is technically a nonprofit group. And it reportedly plans to take care of that nonprofit standing regardless of combining forces with the for-profit LIV tour. The brand new three way partnership can be for-profit, however the PGA would preserve its nonprofit standing.
The concept that federal nonprofit, tax-exempt standing might be stretched to use to a sports activities league with enormous revenues and executives who make thousands and thousands of {dollars} is plainly ridiculous. It might be authorized, however it’s ludicrous. The PGA-LIV merger ought to draw additional consideration and assist to federal efforts, years within the making, that may forestall skilled sports activities leagues from claiming nonprofit standing.
“Sports activities leagues just like the NHL and the PGA Tour present leisure for thousands and thousands of Individuals, however that doesn’t imply these league-specific manufacturers ought to be capable to make the most of Part 501(c)(6) of the tax code to be tax exempt,” Sen. Angus King stated again in 2018 when he joined with Republican Sen. Joni Ernst of Iowa to introduce the Correctly Lowering Overexemptions for Sports activities (PRO Sports activities) Act. “This invoice would assist shut loopholes that enable leagues to spice up their earnings on the expense of taxpayers – it’s simply widespread sense.”
The PGA Tour made a enterprise choice this week to accomplice with LIV Golf. That has not solely chipped away at any ethical excessive floor the PGA may need had, however has additionally pushed house the purpose that they (and different sports activities leagues) mustn’t have nonprofit standing.
